Business people handshaking, making successful deal, partnership agreement, close up, har manager greeting job applicant during interview in office, businessman shaking hand of partner at meeting

During my 40 years in the search business, I have made offers, negotiated offers, and even rescinded a few. Here are some suggestions for both sides:

1. Be prepared. If you are the company, dig in and understand the components of the candidate’s compensation package, including vacation time. If the candidate receives 50% incentive compensation, offering him a 20% base salary increase will not work if your company has no incentive compensation. Similarly, if you are the candidate, understand how your peers are compensated at the new employer so that you will be able to assess the total package being offered.

2. Use the search firm to a point. It is a good idea for the search firm to float the offer in general terms by the candidate. If the employer has made glaring errors in its assumptions, the search firm should serve as a buffer. Similarly, the search firm can be the reality check if the candidate is totally unrealistic in their expectations (“I want a 50% base salary increase”).

3. Put yourself in the other party’s position. See where they are coming from. If the candidate has been making a healthy base salary and smaller bonus, they might be challenged by having to take a cut in base even if they make a lot more at the end of the year. Similarly, if the company does not pay huge bonuses and never has, you, the candidate, can’t expect them to change their policy just for one person.

At some point, cut the search firm out. Once you get a general idea of the compensation package and have some refinements to make, you lose the search firm. It is time for the company and candidate to get to know each other while addressing a challenge that requires a win-win solution. Look at the negotiation to indicate how you and the prospective executive will solve problems together. Working with your future manager to develop a win-win compensation package will tell you much about each other. Is there flexibility? The willingness to be creative? Rigidity? A give and take? Is there a greediness? Entitlement? An ability to see the longer term?  

4. Give positive feedback. When responding to your prospective manager about the offer, start by telling them what you like, followed by the areas that need tweaking: “I am so pleased to receive an offer and believe I can make a huge difference in how the company runs its logistics function. The base salary is very fair. I want to discuss whether we can create a richer incentive bonus based on what I know I can accomplish?” As an employer, start by telling the candidate why they are receiving an offer and how much they look forward to having them as part of the team. Talk about the long-term career path rather than just compensation.

5. Don’t sweat the small stuff if this is the perfect position/manager. If you like the company, position, and manager, don’t let a small amount of money or pride stand in your way. Also, you will look petty if you are negotiating for a few thousand dollars, assuming you will have a career of many years with the company. Similarly, if you are the employer, you want the executive to feel good about joining and don’t want to appear cheap over a few thousand dollars. For both sides, you want to come to the table with a spirit of “let’s get this done quickly and collegially so that we both look back on this negotiation as an easy beginning to a long-term relationship.’ As one client characterized it,” it is a shared risk–the candidate has to trust that we will take care of them long term. I trust that the candidate will make me look suitable for hiring them.

Adrienne McDunn understands difficult people. Especially those in the workplace.

It was a skill established early in McDunn’s career, enabling her to really listen and build connections among coworkers. That intangible ability caught the eye of management, and they assigned her to a project with several “difficult” personalities. Where everyone else saw a tangle of conflict, Adrienne saw opportunity, successfully bringing together the people and the project.

Those interactions laid the groundwork for her role as President and CEO of Personalysis, a science-based tool that assesses an individual by identifying three specific personality parts. The three-in-one assessment defines how a person thinks, makes decisions, processes information, and expresses themselves. It also illuminates their preferred communication style and what they consider meaningful work.

The Houston-based company is a tool in the kit of Fortune 500 organizations and small and medium-sized businesses across a variety of industries. It’s a resource used by The Alexander Group as part of the onboarding process to understand each member of the team better.

“You see someone with brand new eyes,” McDunn said. “You learn to respect their strengths and play to them. It’s a benefit to the team.”

Ideally, Personalysis is used during onboarding, although it’s beneficial for businesses at any point of progress. As companies continue to coalesce post-Covid, Personalysis assessments are helpful for in-person interactions.

“So many teams have been isolated and there’s collapsed relational communication. Methods of communication are more direct, people are more likely to send an email, when some situations benefit from a discussion,” McDunn said.

Adrienne McDunn

The Personalysis assessment involves a selection of questions and one of two choices for each question. There are no wrong answers, but assessment takers have one extreme answer or the other when making selections. That’s intentional, McDunn said.

“We were deliberate on the creation, as it gives us a true read of an individual. We are trying to distinguish characteristics; it reads the way we can see how you operate in the world.”

Around The Alexander Group office, it’s not uncommon to hear phrases such as, “That’s your red coming through” or “That’s how a blue would approach that situation,” because test results are signified by red, yellow, blue, and green. The Red Perspective is the expeditor, Yellow is the collaborator, Blue is the explore,r and Green is the organizer.

Reds like to blast through their to-do list, focusing on simplicity and speed. They are often described as intense and laser-focused. Reds lean toward the questions “What” and “When,” skipping the small talk and heading directly to the point.

Yellows focus on relationships and inclusion, gathering others’ opinions and discussing solution options. A Yellow’s communication style is upbeat and inviting and in meetings, they focus on the positive. Yellow personalities love working with the team on a variety of tasks, helping others along the way.

Blues are visionaries. Their curious and innovative natures keep their minds always busy and their wheels spinning, but rest assured, blues are constantly contemplating scenarios and solutions. Blues rely on context and purpose, and their communication style is inquisitive, clarifying, and informative.

Green’s comfort zone is rooted in stability. They are logical, linear, and logistical, thriving in process-orientated situations. Green relies on verifiable data to make decisions and is the point person for all things organizational. Need to bring order to chaos? That’s a job for Green.

Understanding a team’s personality strengths and differences is beneficial in multiple ways. Focusing on relationships creates a more collegial and productive environment, allowing for coordinated action. Another by-product of building a strong team?

Trust.

“It says you’ve got my back,” McDunn said.

McDunn travels extensively, working with teams of all sizes, but she also spends time with senior executives and board members for in-depth coaching sessions. These sessions help the C-suite understand their personalities, which in turn leads to a more productive work environment.

McDunn believes the power of Personalysis lies not in the color but in the intention each color represents.

“If you become more self-aware, you ask, how do I work better? The tool identifies behaviors and motivation to do that.”

Working better.

Communicating effectively.

Building trust. These are the building blocks for success in and out of the workplace.

Reed Smith LLP enhances global client engagement with the appointment of Gillian Ward.​

Gillian Ward Headshot B&W Reed Smitch LLP

Client: Reed Smith LLP | Role: Chief Marketing and Business Development Officer | Candidate: Gillian Ward

Search Consultants: Amanda K. Brady, Sarah Mitchell, Pam DeLuca​

Overview

Reed Smith LLP, a dynamic international law firm with over 1,700 attorneys across 30 offices worldwide, partnered with The Alexander Group to identify a strategic leader for the Chief Marketing and Business Development Officer role. The firm sought an executive capable of unifying its global marketing and business development strategies to support continued growth and integration.​

Key Leadership Need

The firm required a seasoned professional to align marketing, client development, and operational initiatives across its global platform. The ideal candidate needed extensive experience building integrated strategies across jurisdictions, supporting firm-wide growth, and serving as a key executive partner to the firm’s leadership.​

The Alexander Group’s Approach

The Alexander Group’s executive search team—led by Managing Director and Chief Client Officer Amanda K. Brady, Director Sarah Mitchell, and Associate Pam DeLuca—conducted a comprehensive international search focusing on senior marketing executives with a proven track record in global law firm environments.​

Our Tailored Approach:

  • Developed a tailored search strategy aligned with Reed Smith’s vision for worldwide integration and client-centric growth​
  • Identified senior leaders experienced in marketing transformation and operational execution across multiple geographies​
  • Assessed candidates for executive presence, strategic capability, and alignment with firm leadership​

Successful Placement and Impact

“Gillian is a key strategic hire for our firm as we focus on growing client relationships and expanding our presence in new and existing markets.

– Nick Bagiatis, Chief Operating Officer, Reed Smith LLP

Gillian Ward, formerly the Global Chief Marketing Officer at Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner LLP (US), was appointed Reed Smith’s Chief Marketing and Business Development Officer. She previously held senior leadership roles at Baker Botts LLP and brings extensive expertise in market development, client growth programs, and strategy formulation.​

Immediate benefits:

  • Unified Global Marketing Strategy: Gillian will oversee the integration of marketing and business development functions across Reed Smith’s 30 international offices.​
  • Strategic Growth Leadership: She brings a data-driven, client-focused approach to marketing that supports Reed Smith’s continued platform expansion.​
  • Executive Collaboration: As a key partner to the firm’s leadership, Gillian will contribute directly to high-level strategy and decision-making.​

Insights from the Executive Search Team

“Gillian brings broad experience helping global law firms design and integrate marketing and business development initiatives across practices and continents, ensuring a comprehensive and holistic approach to support growth. She will be a key member of Reed Smith’s executive team and the ideal partner to Chair Casey Ryan and COO Nick Bagiatis as they lead the firm through continued strategic growth of its global platform.”

— Amanda K. Brady, Managing Director and Chief Client Officer, The Alexander Group​

About Reed Smith LLP

Reed Smith LLP is a global law firm known for its deep industry knowledge, collaborative culture, and innovative approach to legal service delivery. With offices in the United States, Europe, the Middle East, and Asia, the firm advises leading businesses on complex litigation, regulatory matters, and high-stakes transactions. Reed Smith is recognized for forging long-term client relationships and delivering forward-thinking legal solutions that support business growth.

About The Alexander Group

Specializing in executive search for law firms and financial leadership roles, The Alexander Group delivers strategic, results-driven placements tailored to each client’s needs.​Interested in learning more about our executive recruitment services? Contact The Alexander Group today.​

Hecker Fink LLP enhances its operational leadership with the appointment of Aurelie Binisti.

Aurelie Binisti HR Director Hecker Fink LLP

Client: Hecker Fink LLP | Role: Human Resources Director | Candidate: Aurelie Binisti

Search Consultant: Sarah Mitchell​

Overview

Hecker Fink LLP, a premier litigation boutique known for its high-stakes legal work and commitment to public interest, partnered with The Alexander Group to identify a Human Resources Director. The firm sought a strategic leader to oversee and enhance its human resources functions, supporting its continued growth and dynamic work environment.​

Key Leadership Need

As Hecker Fink LLP expanded its team of elite litigators and staff, the firm required a human resources executive capable of managing complex HR operations, fostering a collaborative culture, and aligning HR strategies with the firm’s mission of delivering exceptional legal services and advocacy.​

The Alexander Group’s Approach

Director Sarah Mitchell led the search, focusing on candidates with extensive experience in human resources leadership across diverse industries. The search emphasized finding a professional with the adaptability and emotional intelligence to thrive in Hecker Fink’s fast-paced and mission-driven environment.​

Execution Highlights:

  • Developed a tailored search strategy aligned with Hecker Fink’s organizational goals and culture.​
  • Identified candidates with a proven track record in strategic and operational HR management.​
  • Assessed candidates for cultural fit, leadership capabilities, and the ability to contribute to the firm’s continued success.

Successful Placement and Impact

Aurelie Binisti, a seasoned human resources professional with over 15 years of experience in media and financial services, was appointed as Hecker Fink LLP’s Human Resources Director. Prior to joining the firm, she served as Executive Director of Human Resources at OMD for Omnicom. Aurelie holds a master’s degree in human resources from SUP RH in Paris, France.​

Immediate benefits:

  • Strategic HR Leadership: Aurelie brings a wealth of experience in developing and implementing HR strategies that support organizational objectives.​
  • Operational Excellence: Her background ensures efficient management of HR operations, contributing to the firm’s overall performance.​
  • Cultural Alignment: Aurelie’s interpersonal skills and adaptability make her well-suited to foster the firm’s collaborative and high-achieving culture.​

Insights from the Executive Search Consultant

About Hecker Fink LLP

Hecker Fink LLP is a formidable litigation boutique specializing in high-stakes legal matters, including white-collar criminal defense, complex appellate litigation, and public interest cases. The firm is dedicated to achieving the best possible results for clients through fierce advocacy, creative strategies, and forward-looking advice.

About The Alexander Group

Specializing in executive search for law firms and financial leadership roles, The Alexander Group delivers strategic, results-driven placements tailored to each client’s unique needs.​Interested in learning more about our executive recruitment services? Contact The Alexander Group today.​