Business people handshaking, making successful deal, partnership agreement, close up, har manager greeting job applicant during interview in office, businessman shaking hand of partner at meeting

During my 40 years in the search business, I have made offers, negotiated offers, and even rescinded a few. Here are some suggestions for both sides:

1. Be prepared. If you are the company, dig in and understand the components of the candidate’s compensation package, including vacation time. If the candidate receives 50% incentive compensation, offering him a 20% base salary increase will not work if your company has no incentive compensation. Similarly, if you are the candidate, understand how your peers are compensated at the new employer so that you will be able to assess the total package being offered.

2. Use the search firm to a point. It is a good idea for the search firm to float the offer in general terms by the candidate. If the employer has made glaring errors in its assumptions, the search firm should serve as a buffer. Similarly, the search firm can be the reality check if the candidate is totally unrealistic in their expectations (“I want a 50% base salary increase”).

3. Put yourself in the other party’s position. See where they are coming from. If the candidate has been making a healthy base salary and smaller bonus, they might be challenged by having to take a cut in base even if they make a lot more at the end of the year. Similarly, if the company does not pay huge bonuses and never has, you, the candidate, can’t expect them to change their policy just for one person.

At some point, cut the search firm out. Once you get a general idea of the compensation package and have some refinements to make, you lose the search firm. It is time for the company and candidate to get to know each other while addressing a challenge that requires a win-win solution. Look at the negotiation to indicate how you and the prospective executive will solve problems together. Working with your future manager to develop a win-win compensation package will tell you much about each other. Is there flexibility? The willingness to be creative? Rigidity? A give and take? Is there a greediness? Entitlement? An ability to see the longer term?  

4. Give positive feedback. When responding to your prospective manager about the offer, start by telling them what you like, followed by the areas that need tweaking: “I am so pleased to receive an offer and believe I can make a huge difference in how the company runs its logistics function. The base salary is very fair. I want to discuss whether we can create a richer incentive bonus based on what I know I can accomplish?” As an employer, start by telling the candidate why they are receiving an offer and how much they look forward to having them as part of the team. Talk about the long-term career path rather than just compensation.

5. Don’t sweat the small stuff if this is the perfect position/manager. If you like the company, position, and manager, don’t let a small amount of money or pride stand in your way. Also, you will look petty if you are negotiating for a few thousand dollars, assuming you will have a career of many years with the company. Similarly, if you are the employer, you want the executive to feel good about joining and don’t want to appear cheap over a few thousand dollars. For both sides, you want to come to the table with a spirit of “let’s get this done quickly and collegially so that we both look back on this negotiation as an easy beginning to a long-term relationship.’ As one client characterized it,” it is a shared risk–the candidate has to trust that we will take care of them long term. I trust that the candidate will make me look suitable for hiring them.

Hecker Fink LLP enhances its operational leadership with the appointment of Aurelie Binisti.

Aurelie Binisti HR Director Hecker Fink LLP

Client: Hecker Fink LLP | Role: Human Resources Director | Candidate: Aurelie Binisti

Search Consultant: Sarah Mitchell​

Overview

Hecker Fink LLP, a premier litigation boutique known for its high-stakes legal work and commitment to public interest, partnered with The Alexander Group to identify a Human Resources Director. The firm sought a strategic leader to oversee and enhance its human resources functions, supporting its continued growth and dynamic work environment.​

Key Leadership Need

As Hecker Fink LLP expanded its team of elite litigators and staff, the firm required a human resources executive capable of managing complex HR operations, fostering a collaborative culture, and aligning HR strategies with the firm’s mission of delivering exceptional legal services and advocacy.​

The Alexander Group’s Approach

Director Sarah Mitchell led the search, focusing on candidates with extensive experience in human resources leadership across diverse industries. The search emphasized finding a professional with the adaptability and emotional intelligence to thrive in Hecker Fink’s fast-paced and mission-driven environment.​

Execution Highlights:

  • Developed a tailored search strategy aligned with Hecker Fink’s organizational goals and culture.​
  • Identified candidates with a proven track record in strategic and operational HR management.​
  • Assessed candidates for cultural fit, leadership capabilities, and the ability to contribute to the firm’s continued success.

Successful Placement and Impact

Aurelie Binisti, a seasoned human resources professional with over 15 years of experience in media and financial services, was appointed as Hecker Fink LLP’s Human Resources Director. Prior to joining the firm, she served as Executive Director of Human Resources at OMD for Omnicom. Aurelie holds a master’s degree in human resources from SUP RH in Paris, France.​

Immediate benefits:

  • Strategic HR Leadership: Aurelie brings a wealth of experience in developing and implementing HR strategies that support organizational objectives.​
  • Operational Excellence: Her background ensures efficient management of HR operations, contributing to the firm’s overall performance.​
  • Cultural Alignment: Aurelie’s interpersonal skills and adaptability make her well-suited to foster the firm’s collaborative and high-achieving culture.​

Insights from the Executive Search Consultant

About Hecker Fink LLP

Hecker Fink LLP is a formidable litigation boutique specializing in high-stakes legal matters, including white-collar criminal defense, complex appellate litigation, and public interest cases. The firm is dedicated to achieving the best possible results for clients through fierce advocacy, creative strategies, and forward-looking advice.

About The Alexander Group

Specializing in executive search for law firms and financial leadership roles, The Alexander Group delivers strategic, results-driven placements tailored to each client’s unique needs.​Interested in learning more about our executive recruitment services? Contact The Alexander Group today.​

Tony Capecci has joined Haynes and Boone, LLP as Director of Practice Innovation.

Mr. Capecci is an experienced legal technology leader with two decades of experience in legal technology and more than a decade of experience spearheading the procurement, development, and implementation of legal systems in fast-paced environments.

Prior to joining Haynes & Boone, Mr. Capecci was Associate Director, Litigation & Practice Delivery at Kirkland & Ellis. Mr. Capecci received a Bachelor of Arts in Interactive Multimedia from Columbia College Chicago.

Director Sarah Mitchell and Senior Associate Michael Doering conducted and completed this search.

“Tony has a deep understanding of the technology needs of a practicing lawyer, coupled with the leadership, intellectual curiosity, and passion for innovation needed to succeed in this role,” said Mitchell.

Haynes and Boone, LLP is a highly respected American Lawyer top 100 law firm, with more than 600 lawyers and 425 non-lawyer employees in 18 domestic and three international offices, and over 40 major practices.

The firm has grown from a two-person firm in 1970 to a global leader through its client-first focus, which informs its decisions and processes, and the collaborative nature of its people, which makes the work environment healthy and pleasant.

The firm’s culture focuses on teamwork, an environment of mutual respect, and a long-term view that supports investing in the future.

Tony Dorazio has joined Aither Systems as Chief Executive Officer.

Aither Systems is a growing company commercializing Energy as a Service solutions for the telecom sector. The company designs, builds, operates, and monitors microgrids, control software and related infrastructure, which optimize asset resiliency and reduce carbon emissions. Aither recently received an investment from EnCap’s Energy Transition Fund.

Mr. Dorazio is a seasoned power industry executive with more than 20 years of global experience in companies with scales ranging from utilities to distributed generation to microgrids, and he has built and led organizations focusing on solar, wind, and battery energy storage technologies. Mr. Dorazio received an MBA from Long Island University and a Bachelor of Science in Electromechanical Engineering Technology from State University of New York.

Director Leah Salinas and Managing Director Jonathan Verlander conducted and completed this search.

“Tony is a highly experienced leader who brings a unique blend of experiences to this role. The Aither and EnCap teams are excited to see the impact he will have as Chief Executive of the company,” Leah SalinasDirectorThe Alexander Group. “We were very pleased to partner again with EnCap’s Energy Transition team on this search, and we look forward to continuing to support them in the future.”

Aither Systems is a growing company that is commercializing Energy as a Service solutions 
(focused on behind-the-meter energy capture, storage, and management) for the telecom sector.

The company designs, builds, operates, and monitors microgrids, control software and related infrastructure, which optimize asset resiliency and reduce carbon emissions. The company has developed multiple promising product lines and is in the initial stages of commercialization with a major telecom provider.

Global law firm Morrison & Foerster enhances operational leadership with the appointment of Brian Gross as Chief Operating Officer.

Headshot of Brian Gross for Morrison & Foerster LLP

Client: Morrison & Foerster LLP | Role: Chief Operating Officer | Candidate: Brian Gross

Recruiters: John Lamar, Managing Director and Sarah Mitchell, Director

Overview

Morrison & Foerster LLP (MoFo), a premier global law firm recognized for its work in technology, life sciences, finance, and litigation, partnered with The Alexander Group, a global executive search firm, to recruit a Chief Operating Officer (COO). As Morrison & Foerster continues to scale its international operations and deliver innovation-driven client service, the firm sought an experienced leader to optimize its business functions, drive operational excellence, and support long-term strategic growth.

Key Leadership Need

The firm required a Chief Operating Officer who could oversee the firm’s operational, financial, administrative, and marketing functions on a firmwide basis. The ideal candidate would enhance collaboration across practice groups and business services, strengthen internal systems, and align firm operations with Morrison & Foerster’s global growth strategy while maintaining its culture of innovation and service excellence.

The Alexander Group’s Approach

Managing Director John Lamar and Director Sarah Mitchell led a targeted executive search, focused on identifying operational leaders from top-tier law firms and professional services organizations.

Key priorities included:

  • Proven leadership across finance, HR, IT, marketing, and administrative operations
  • Expertise in driving business growth, operational transformation, and strategic initiatives
  • Success leading cross-functional teams and fostering collaborative, high-performance cultures

Brian Gross was selected for his strategic leadership at Boston Consulting Group (BCG), where he served as COO for North America and Managing Director and Partner, as well as for his proven ability to build high-performing teams and operationalize firm-wide growth strategies.

Successful Placement and Impact

Brian Gross joined Morrison & Foerster LLP as Chief Operating Officer. With over two decades of leadership experience across professional services, including BCG and prior business development and recruiting leadership roles, Brian now leads MoFo’s financial, operational, marketing, and administrative functions globally.

Immediate Impact:

  • Strengthening alignment of business operations with firmwide strategic initiatives
  • Optimizing internal processes to support cross-office collaboration and client service delivery
  • Building operational teams and infrastructure to sustain long-term growth and innovation

Insights from the Recruiters

“Brian’s extensive experience as a senior operations executive, his demonstrated ability to build and lead teams, and his strong strategic skills will serve Morrison Foerster well as the firm continues to expand its global platform.”

 — John Lamar, Managing Director, and Sarah Mitchell, Director, The Alexander Group

About Morrison & Foerster LLP

Morrison & Foerster LLP is a leading global law firm with more than 1,000 attorneys across 17 offices worldwide. The firm is widely recognized for its innovation, diversity, and outstanding client service across sectors including technology, life sciences, finance, and litigation.

About The Alexander Group

The Alexander Group is a global executive search firm and an executive search firm in Houston. The firm serves industries including legal services, life sciences, healthcare, financial services, energy, technology, consumer goods, and nonprofit organizations, delivering strategic, results-driven leadership placements tailored to each client’s needs.

Interested in learning more about our executive recruitment services? Contact The Alexander Group today.

Washington, D.C.–based law firm, Wiley Rein LLP, strengthens financial leadership with the appointment of Brad Bonneau as CFO.

Headshot of Brad Bonneau as CFO for Wiley Rein LLP

Client: Wiley Rein LLP | Role: Chief Financial Officer | Candidate: Brad Bonneau

Recruiters: Managing Director/Chief Client Officer Amanda K. Brady and Senior Associate Michael Doering

Overview

Wiley Rein LLP, a nationally recognized law firm renowned for its expertise in regulatory, litigation, and government affairs, has partnered with The Alexander Group, a global executive search firm, to recruit a Chief Financial Officer (CFO). As the firm continued to expand its national footprint and practice capabilities, it required a seasoned financial leader to optimize financial operations, implement scalable processes, and drive data-informed decision-making.

Key Leadership Need

The firm needed a CFO who could oversee all financial functions, including budgeting, financial reporting, forecasting, client funds management, billing and collections, and audit oversight. Wiley sought a leader capable of strengthening financial performance, modernizing internal accounting systems, and supporting strategic growth initiatives across multiple practice groups.

The Alexander Group’s Approach

The Alexander Group conducted a targeted national search for finance executives with deep expertise in professional services operations, particularly within the legal sector.

Search strategy highlights:

  • Identified CFOs experienced in budgeting, projections, client pricing models, and audit oversight
  • Prioritized candidates with a strong background in law firm accounting systems and financial reporting
  • Emphasized leadership skills in managing financial teams and driving operational improvements

Brad Bonneau emerged as the top candidate based on his extensive financial leadership experience at Chapman and Cutler LLP, where he served as CFO, and his proven ability to modernize finance functions while mentoring and developing professional accounting teams.

Successful Placement and Impact

Brad Bonneau joined Wiley Rein LLP as Chief Financial Officer. He brings over two decades of financial leadership experience in the legal sector, including financial planning and analysis, budgeting, client fund management, tax compliance, and optimization of accounting systems.

Immediate Impact:

  • Initiated upgrades to financial reporting and internal accounting processes
  • Strengthened budgeting and forecasting accuracy across the firm
  • Developed streamlined models for client billing and alternative pricing strategies
  • Enhanced collaboration between finance and practice leadership teams

Insights from the Recruiters

“Brad is the ideal strategic business partner to Wiley’s forward-thinking executive team.”

-Amanda K. Brady, Managing Director/Chief Client Officer at The Alexander Group.

About Wiley Rein LLP

Wiley Rein LLP is a Washington, D.C.–based law firm with more than 240 attorneys practicing in areas such as telecom, insurance, government contracts, and public policy. Known for its focus on regulatory and litigation matters, the firm has earned a strong reputation for delivering strategic client solutions.

About The Alexander Group

The Alexander Group is a global executive search firm with offices in Houston and other U.S. cities. Serving industries including legal services, life sciences, healthcare, financial services, energy, technology, consumer goods, and nonprofit organizations, The Alexander Group specializes in delivering strategic, results-driven leadership placements tailored to each client’s needs.

Interested in learning more about our executive recruitment services? Contact The Alexander Group today.

Board members and interns discussing the benefits of board membership

The benefits of board membership extend far beyond prestige or compensation; they offer executives a chance to grow professionally, make meaningful contributions, and build valuable networks. 

However, serving on a public company board is not as easy as it once was. Increased regulatory pressures, shareholder scrutiny, and the risk of litigation have elevated board members’ responsibilities. 

Despite these challenges, many public companies continue to attract highly competent directors. Why is this so? Because the opportunities and rewards of board membership make it a compelling career move for many executives.

Seven Benefits of Board Membership

The benefits of board membership are as diverse as the professionals who seek them. From career advancement to personal fulfillment, board service offers executives opportunities to grow, contribute, and connect meaningfully.

In this section, we’ll explore seven compelling reasons why board membership remains an attractive goal for many leaders.

As executives move into the last third of their careers, many start planning their retirement and what they will do to fill the time. If we had a dime for every executive who says, “Once I retire, I’d like to sit on a couple of boards,” our coffers would overflow. 

With board memberships, a retired (or nearly retired) executive can have a place in the business world but on a more limited and structured basis. No analyst meetings, no customer presentations. Just three days a quarter, often in a nice location. As one executive said, “I don’t want to practice, but I still want to be in the game.”

Many executives in the prime of their careers want to be on a board so they can learn from other executives and see what works for a different company, industry, or culture. Susan R. Nowakowski, President and CEO of AMN Healthcare Services, says that a board position should allow executives an opportunity to be constantly challenged and grow professionally. 

She adds that directors should “get involved in addressing the organization’s key strategic issues by joining, and perhaps even chairing, the board’s strategic planning committee because strategic acumen and leadership abilities are valued in the business world.”

There are many executives who like being exposed to other executives—whether for business reasons or simple networking reasons. It is not uncommon to see some potential board candidates choose to join a board based on the perceived caliber and stature of the other board members.

Similarly, we have conducted searches where prospective candidates have commented that the board we were recruiting for was “not high wattage” enough for them.

Make no mistake: serving on a public company board can provide attractive compensation, leaving many professionals wondering, ‘How much do board members make?’ 

With roughly 20 work days a year, board members can earn substantial fees, often supplemented by stock options. While many companies award a portion of board fees in the form of stock options, the potential for stock appreciation can also be a strong incentive. 

Top corporate board earner Shirley A. Jackson, who sits on six Fortune 500 boards, including FedEx, Marathon Oil, and IBM, took home more than $4 million in board compensation from 2008 to 2010.

Right or wrong, some executives see a board seat as one more rung in a successful career. We have met executives who don’t have the time or, truth be told, the attention to detail that a board requires, yet still, they believe they are missing something by not serving. It’s almost like the corporate version of “Keeping Up with the Jones.” 

Listen carefully, for the stories are plentiful of board members ever so quietly being asked to leave for not attending board meetings or being unprepared.

Many executives believe that board service will provide greater visibility, making them more sought after for a higher position with another company. This seems especially true with non-CEOs. We know a former CFO of a utility company who landed a spot on a Fortune 50 consumer products board. Many years later, while being considered for the CEO position of his business, he beat out someone with much more experience because the board believed his knowledge as a board member for another company would make him more effective at managing their board. Along these lines, some companies choose their CEO from their existing Board members.

While most board members don’t join a company board hoping to be its CEO, it does happen. Betsy Burton, the former CEO of Supercuts, sat on the board of jewelry retailer Zale Corporation for three years before being selected as President and CEO. From July 2009 to October 2010, twelve Fortune 1000 companies selected their new permanent or interim CEO from their board ranks, up from only four the year before, and the trend is only growing.

Depending on their expertise, executives can pick from a list of executive board positions such as Chairperson, Treasurer, or strategic committee leadership roles, expanding their career opportunities through targeted board memberships.

Some executives don’t care about any of the above reasons but want to serve; they believe they have the wisdom and experience to add value to a particular organization. As Thomas M. Gorrie, a renowned international health policy adviser, said when he was selected to join The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation’s board of directors, “I am eager to lend my experience and passion…to help continue the foundation’s reputation for innovation and excellence and to play a role in helping achieve lasting change in health and health care.” 

Executives drawn to service often find fulfillment in the responsibilities of a board member, which include providing governance, offering strategic oversight, and ensuring the organization’s long-term success.

Maximizing the Benefits of Board Membership: Your Next Professional Move

Board service offers a unique blend of professional growth, personal fulfillment, and career advancement opportunities. From leveraging your expertise in a strategic capacity to building meaningful connections with other leaders, serving on a board can be a pivotal step in your professional journey. Whether you’re nearing retirement, seeking a new challenge, or simply want to contribute your knowledge and passion to a worthy organization, the benefits of board membership are as diverse as the roles themselves.If you’re considering board service as your next professional move, The Alexander Group can help you navigate the process. With decades of experience in executive search and board placements, we specialize in matching exceptional leaders with organizations that align with their values and expertise. Contact us today to explore how we can support your transition to board service and help you find the perfect fit for your skills and ambitions.

Random dialogue clouds suggesting board member communication between several board members

Board member communication is a critical skill that can shape the effectiveness and dynamics of any board. From asking thoughtful questions to influencing decisions through collaboration, how an effective board of directors communicates often determines its success. 

This guide is the third in our series exploring proven strategies for helping first-time and seasoned board members refine their communication styles and build stronger connections. If you missed our previous posts, you can find part one here and part two here.

6 Board Member Communication Tips

One of our readers suggested that you think of your first board as if you are being introduced to your spouse-to-be’s family. Maybe that is not the perfect analogy, but first impressions are hard to counterbalance should you make a mistake.

As a board director, how you communicate is just as important as what you do. Successful directors think before they speak and influence their peers instead of making demands. Continue reading for more expert advice on effectively communicating as a board director.

Think before you speak. Ask yourself: 

  • What is my intent? 
  • What is my objective? 

One savvy director says he phrases his questions to promote discussion and allow the board to examine the issue more deeply.

You need not always ask the first question or make the first comment on a topic. There will be times when you can offer more by listening first to what others have to say. As we noted previously, refrain from asking questions merely to get information you should already have; in other words, do your homework so you don’t have to use meeting time to get up to speed. If you have unanswered questions, schedule one-on-one calls or meetings with the CEO or other directors before the meeting and during breaks.

Know what matters and what does not because time is limited. One veteran director comments, “There is always a director who wants to monopolize the conversation and listen to himself talk. Don’t be that person.”

Stick to the essentials for effective board meetings and action. If the conversation derails, gently guide everyone back to the topic. Details matter and often merit discussion, but avoid “the weeds” unless the issue is the weeds. Those are better left to management.

You will have a different kind of authority than a director on your first public board as a CEO, where you have the final say. A board meeting is not a staff meeting where you make unilateral decisions and assign tasks. One director, a managing partner at a private equity firm, confessed that after being on the board of portfolio companies where he didn’t have to share power with others, joining a public board required him to modify his style to stop giving orders and rely more on influence.

Because boards act collectively and not individually, effective directors must act through persuasion, convincing others of the merits—and the risks—of a particular decision. Becoming an influential board member requires understanding how other directors receive and process information. You will never finish refining your ability to influence.

Use your experience as an executive officer at other companies without constantly referring to it. As one director said, “It is very annoying for someone to continually say, ‘At ABC company, we always did this.’” Constantly bringing up your experience as an executive may turn off management and your fellow directors.

Instead, one veteran director suggests asking open-ended questions that compare strategies. “Could there be a better way to do this?” works much better than “At my company, we do it differently.” Balancing input and collaboration with others is one of the key responsibilities of a board member. This ensures that your experience adds value without overshadowing group dynamics.

Director communication should be on a two-way street, not limited to the boardroom or committee room. Most boards have a formal director evaluation process; let that assessment be an ongoing process and seek out the views of other directors on a range of relevant matters. One of the most valuable things a new director can do is ask for feedback on their board participation after the first or second meeting. If you are talking too much, focusing on the wrong issues, or crossing the line on management responsibilities, learning it quickly to adapt is better. Seeking constructive feedback is a vital step in learning how to be a good board member, helping you identify areas for improvement and build stronger relationships with fellow directors.

After you have gained experience serving on the board, be a helpful leader to any new directors. An experienced board director suggests providing positive feedback to new board members by starting with positive recognition: “I like the way you did this. However, when you said that, you turned the management off. Is there a better way you could approach that?” Many first-time board directors may be insecure initially; the seasoned director has an opportunity to mentor and guide the new director to be effective. Understanding what makes a good board member involves fostering open communication, offering peer support, and continuously improving your ability to collaborate.

Effective Board Member Communication Can Enhance Your Leadership

Mastering board member communication is essential for building trust, fostering collaboration, and driving effective decision-making within any board. You can elevate your contributions and influence as a director by asking thoughtful questions, adapting your style, and providing constructive feedback.
If you’re ready to enhance your board’s leadership and find directors who excel in communication and collaboration, The Alexander Group can help. Contact us today to learn how our executive search expertise can support your organization’s success.

Lauren Elkhoury has joined Vinson & Elkins as Director of Pricing and Rates. Ms. Elkhoury is a cross-functional leader with extensive experience identifying and planning strategic initiatives to maximize revenue and profitability competitively.

Prior to joining Vinson & Elkins, Ms. Elkhoury Director, Practice Operations for Norton Rose Fulbright US LLP in Houston, Texas. Ms. Elkhoury received a Bachelor of Arts in Political Science from Tulane University.

“Lauren is a seasoned legal professional who will bring years of legal project management, pricing, and practice operations experience to Vinson & Elkins. She is known for her ability to plan strategic initiatives to maximize revenue and profitability competitively,” said Anthony OttSenior AssociateThe Alexander Group.

Managing Director John Mann and Senior Associate Anthony Ott conducted and completed this search.

Vinson & Elkins LLP is one of the largest and most successful law firms in the United States, with approximately 700 attorneys. V&E consistently ranks as one of the most profitable law firms and is ranked 25th in the Am Law 100 with respect to 2023 based on profit per equity partner.

Collaborating seamlessly across 11 offices worldwide, V&E provides outstanding client service. The Firm’s lawyers and other professionals are committed to excellence, offering clients experience in handling their transactions, investments, projects, and disputes across the globe. Established in 1917, the Firm’s time-tested role as trusted advisor has made V&E a go-to law firm for many of the world’s leading businesses and investors. 

Illustration of teamwork with gears and lightbulbs symbolizing innovation and collaboration, supporting executive job search tips.

Executive job search tips can make or break your chances of landing a leadership role, especially when working with executive job search firms and experienced recruiters.

We’ve written advice on how to best prepare for, maximize, and manage meetings during a search process, whether with a search committee, a board of directors, videoconferencing, or a conference call.

Understanding executive job interview tips and showcasing qualities of professionalism are essential steps in setting yourself apart from other candidates. After all, professionalism in the workplace isn’t just about appearances—it’s about ensuring your actions align with your words and reflect your capabilities as a leader.

How to Lose Jobs and Alienate Interviewers

Generally, most successful senior executives are adept and experienced at the executive search process, but not all. And the exceptions have stood out vividly. Here are a few real-life examples of executive behaviors that have left these executive search professionals less than impressed.

Four Insights to Help You Succeed in the Executive Recruitment Process

Match your talk to your walk.

How you conduct yourself during the search process speaks volumes about how you engage as a professional and business leader. It is an opportunity to “walk the walk,” not just “talk the talk.”

A Chief Operating Officer may say that he is “highly analytical, data-centric, and impeccably precise,” but if he repeatedly asks for schedules and agendas to be re-sent, does not remember the names of people he has met with, product lines, or critical business metrics; and (despite multiple corrections) continues to bafflingly mispronounce the company’s two-syllable name—your actions are speaking louder than your words.

Likewise, if you’re 

you aren’t projecting the level of functional expertise commensurate with your profession.

Little things make a big impression.

Details matter, and making sure the fine points and “little things” are covered and done correctly is essential for success—as a Chief Executive Officer candidate recently learned. Having spent days and weeks flawlessly preparing, she called in a panic two hours before her final meeting with the board after realizing she had mistakenly flown to the wrong city. She was not selected for the role. 

We recognize that many employers no longer require regular formal business wear in the office. However, it was clear that a candidate was not ready for prime time when he arrived to interview in a suit that had been out of use for so long that dusty coat hanger creases were permanently etched into the shoulder blades.

My colleague Jane Howze describes a search committee search she ran a few years ago: “The committee was deadlocked between two outstanding candidates. What broke the deadlock was that one of the candidates answered questions with ‘What WE need to do,’ while the other candidate responded with ‘What YOU all should do.’”

Small stuff? “Absolutely,” Jane agrees, “but one candidate had already aligned herself with the organization.” She was offered the position. Demonstrating business professionalism means being detail-oriented and prepared, ensuring that even minor oversights don’t overshadow your otherwise strong candidacy.

Where was I? Oh, yes…Stay on point

While the best leaders in their fields have a clear and tangible passion for their work, savvy executives also know how to express that passion in proportion to the receptiveness of their audience and the purpose of a discussion. Do not frantically whiteboard ideas like Russell Crowe in “A Beautiful Mind” to explain your vision. Instead, be nimble and calibrate your message to your audience.

Relatedly, it’s always important to remember to stay on point—especially if you tend to go off on a tangent. If the visual representation of your response to a simple question looks like this…

“I arrived at the firm to lead a significant turnaround; revenue was down 20 percent.”

“I joined on the same day as the firm’s new General Counsel. She had come to the firm from IBM. My brother once worked for IBM. He lives in Wyoming now. I’m headed to Wyoming in two weeks for a vacation. Three years ago, my wife and I vacationed in Paris. It was a nightmare getting there. Our original flight out was canceled, etc.”

…then, your ratio of digressions to relevant points needs inverting.

Where there’s a will, there’s a way.

Scheduling meetings between hyper-busy executives is always challenging. Most of us have calendars and schedules bursting at the seams. However, offering a 45-minute window of availability during June does not demonstrate priority, flexibility, or your willingness to participate in the process.

Along the same lines, constantly demonstrating to a company that you are “pleased where I am,” that it would “take something extraordinary for me to leave,” or that you “could not imagine a better situation than I currently have,” rather than demonstrating why the organization needs you, will not motivate a company to take those “extraordinary” steps.

As we have said before, it is always crucial to “stick the landing.” Sending thoughtful thank you notes to follow up after meetings can be a differentiating touch. Just be sure you have the correct email addresses and that the note to Phil Jones, Firm X, Managing Partner, doesn’t accidentally go to Phil Jones, Firm X, Database Intern.

Mastering Executive Job Search Tips for Success

The executive job search process requires attention to detail, professionalism, and strategic preparation. Avoiding these common missteps ensures you present yourself as the polished leader organizations seek.

While the best executive job search sites can provide helpful tools, partnering with experienced executive search professionals like The Alexander Group offers personalized insights and guidance beyond what online platforms offer. 

For more executive job search tips, follow The Alexander Group on LinkedIn and explore our blog for additional resources to advance your career.